The Adoption Myth That Kept This Woman Sick for Decades

Julie Brumley, a trauma-informed coach and domestic same-race adoptee, shattered the myth that loving families prevent adoption trauma. After thirty years of believing her "perfect" adoption meant she was immune to trauma, a professor's warning launched her into a decade-long healing journey that transformed her understanding of cellular memory and body-based recovery.

Her story on the Voices of Adoption, reveals the hidden reality that even same-race, infant adoptions create pre-verbal trauma requiring specialized therapeutic approaches. aches. Research from the Dept. of Psychology, University of Minnesota shows that adoptees face twice the risk of ADHD diagnosis compared to non-adopted children, with 14-15 out of 100 adopted adolescents receiving this diagnosis versus just 7-8 out of 100 non-adopted children. According to polyvagal theory research, unlike traditional talk therapy, which addresses only 20% of brain-body communication, somatic approaches work with the 80% of messages that travel from body to brain, making them essential for adoptees whose trauma occurred before language development. Through somatic therapy and EMDR, Julie developed revolutionary methods that help adoptees move from external validation to authentic self-belonging, proving that healing is possible when we address trauma where it lives in the nervous system.

Shattering the Perfect Adoption Myth  

The narrative of the "grateful adoptee" prevents many from recognizing legitimate trauma responses. Julie's experience illustrates this dangerous blind spot - despite loving, supportive adoptive parents, she carried unexplained anxiety, people-pleasing behaviors, and persistent feelings of not belonging. The turning point came during graduate studies when a professor delivered a stark warning that unresolved adoption trauma would harm others in her professional practice.

This confrontation shattered Julie's carefully constructed narrative that her loving family meant she escaped adoption's negative impacts. The professor's intervention represents what many adoptees need but rarely receive - direct acknowledgment that adoption inherently involves loss requiring processing. Academic research from studies published in PMC databases supports this reality, showing adoptees are consistently over represented in mental health settings compared to non-adopted peers, regardless of adoptive home quality.

The myth of "perfect adoption" actually hinders healing by preventing adoptees from accessing specialized support. Even the most loving adoptive environments cannot completely mitigate preverbal separation trauma impact. As trauma expert Nancy Verrier explains in her groundbreaking work "The Primal Wound," the separation of a child from its biological mother creates wounds that are "physical, emotional, psychological, and spiritual." Society's expectation of gratitude silences adoptees' legitimate need to process complex emotions surrounding their earliest life experiences, creating what adoptees describe as feeling "fundamentally at war with yourself" when suppressing their authentic experience.

The Seven-Week Journey Through Multiple Caregivers  

Julie's early trauma reveals the layered complexity of adoption wounds extending far beyond placement with adoptive parents. Her first seven weeks involved surviving two abortion attempts, followed by care from four different caregivers before reaching her adoptive family. This level of early disruption creates what trauma specialists recognize as complex developmental trauma during the most neurologically vulnerable period of human development.

Each caregiver transition represented another break in the developing nervous system's attempt to establish safety and connection. Research on early brain development shows infants begin forming attachment patterns immediately after birth. When early weeks involve multiple disruptions, the developing brain learns to expect abandonment rather than safety. As noted in current adoption and mental health research, children adopted before 12 months of age are more likely to develop secure attachment patterns, yet Julie's multiple early transitions created complex trauma that manifested decades later. Her later intimacy struggles directly reflect these early neurological adaptations to unpredictable care giving.

The mysterious woman who attempted to intervene in Julie's adoption adds another complexity layer. This individual's attempt to convince Julie's birth mother to parent represents the ambiguous loss characterizing many adoption stories. These partial connections create additional grief and confusion that adoptees carry without conscious memory but with full bodily impact, creating symptoms that seem to have no logical origin.

When the Body Remembers What the Mind Cannot  

Preverbal trauma manifests in unexpected ways, particularly during intimate moments. Julie experienced "flashbacks to nothing" during intimate moments that felt like dissociation with no apparent trigger, yet represented her body's accurate memory of early abandonment terror. As Bessel van der Kolk explains in "The Body Keeps the Score," traumatized people "chronically feel unsafe inside their bodies" because the past remains "alive in the form of gnawing interior discomfort." Traditional talk therapy proved inadequate because these memories exist below conscious recollection and verbal processing levels.

EMDR therapy research from the EMDR Institute shows superior outcomes in multiple studies, with seven out of ten studies reporting EMDR more rapid and effective than trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy. The Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense list EMDR as a "best practice" for treating PTSD, while the World Health Organization officially approves it for trauma treatment. Julie required multiple EMDR rounds combined with somatic therapy to access and process preverbal experiences. The combination of eye movement processing with body awareness techniques allowed her to discharge trauma energy trapped in her nervous system for decades.

The breakthrough came when Julie learned to identify and track body sensations rather than trying to understand experiences through cognitive analysis alone. This shift from thinking about trauma to feeling through trauma represents the fundamental difference between traditional and somatic healing approaches. Her nervous system began recognizing present-moment safety instead of defending against past threats, enabling genuine intimacy for the first time.

The Revolution Program and Nervous System Regulation  

Julie's systematic approach addresses specific challenges adoptees face in developing authentic self-worth and connection. Her seven-phase Revolution program guides adoptees through structured healing that recognizes adoption trauma's unique nature while building practical nervous system regulation skills. This approach acknowledges that adoptees must learn distinguishing between past trauma responses and present-moment reality.

The program emphasizes moving from external validation to self-belonging, addressing core challenges adoptees face in developing authentic identity. Many adoptees become expert at reading others' needs while remaining disconnected from internal experience. Julie's methodology teaches adoptees to recognize trauma responses before they become overwhelming, identify differences between anger and grief, develop regulation techniques independent of external validation, practice self-compassion during difficult experiences, and build authentic connections based on genuine self-knowledge.

The program integrates EFT tapping and somatic techniques reflecting current trauma treatment understanding that must address both psychological and physiological healing aspects. Neuroscience research from leading somatic therapy experts shows emotions typically take sixty to ninety seconds to pass through the body naturally, but trauma survivors often interrupt this process through dissociation or suppression. As Julie discovered through her own healing, "I will not succumb to outside energy if it doesn't align with my inside energy" - a mantra that helped her distinguish between authentic internal experience and external pressure to perform. Her approach teaches adoptees to stay present with emotional experience long enough for natural resolution to occur.

Transform Your Adoption Journey Through Body-Based Healing  

Adoptees struggling with unexplained anxiety, relationship difficulties, or persistent feelings of not belonging can find hope in recognizing adoption as inherently traumatic, requiring specialized healing approaches. Julie's transformation from confused adoptee to skilled trauma coach demonstrates healing possibilities when adoptees receive appropriate support addressing both psychological and physiological early separation impact.

If you recognize yourself in Julie's "perfect adoption" story that still left you struggling with mysterious symptoms, consider exploring somatic therapy or EMDR with adoption-competent therapists. Your body holds memories and wisdom needed for healing, but accessing that wisdom requires approaches speaking your nervous system's language rather than only your thinking mind. As Julie learned from C.S. Lewis's insight, "I sat with my anger long enough until she told me she was grief" - recognizing that anger often masks deeper loss is essential for authentic healing. As featured on the Voices of Adoption, Julie's work represents the growing movement toward trauma-informed adoption support honoring both gratitude adoptees may feel and grief they inevitably carry.

Ready to begin your adoption trauma healing journey? Connect with adoption-competent therapists who understand preverbal separation trauma's unique challenges and can guide you toward specialized approaches facilitating genuine recovery and authentic self-connection.

Follow or Subscribe to Voices of Adoption on your favorite platform:
Website:www.VoicesofAdoption.org
YouTube: @Voicesof_Adoption
Twitter/X: @Voices_Adoption
Instagram: @Voicesof_Adoption 
Facebook: Voices of Adoption
TikTok: @Voices_of_Adoption 
LinkedIn: @Voices-of-Adoption